An infinitary rule of inference in the language of arithmetic according to which when holds of every natural number , then may be inferred. Formally, this inference may be represented as:
The addition of the -rule to first-order Peano arithmetic produces a stronger theory. Where is the arithmetical formula corresponding to ‘ encodes a proof terminating with the formula encoded by ,’ Peano Arithmetic proves for every standard natural number , i.e., proves of any standard that does not encode a proof of the absurd sentence . Were one to employ the rule, then, one could make the following inference:
But the conclusion is just the sentence describing the consistency of , i.e., , which cannot be proved in , by Gödel’s First Incompleteness Theorem.